The Resurgence of Conservatism
I. The Election of Ronald Reagan
a. New Right
i. The “Old Right” had been Southerners and Westerners who advocated States’ rights and harbored suspicions of federal power
ii. Gained momentum from the countercultural protests of the 1960s. They were concerned about social issues
iii. They denounced:
1. Abortion
2. Pornography
3. Homosexuality
4. Feminism
5. Affirmative action
iv. They advocated:
1. Prayer in schools
2. Tougher penalties for criminals
b. Reagan’s Political Ideas
i. Was brought up in a generation whose values were formed well before the upheavals of the 1960s
ii. Sided with the New Right
iii. Denounced activist government; championed the “common man” against big business
iv. Condemned:
1. Federal intervention in local affairs
2. Favoritism for minorities
3. Elite and arrogant bureaucrats
c. Neoconservatives
i. Drew on the ideas of “neoconservatives,” who:
1. Championed free-market capitalism with no government restraints as domestic policy
2. Tough anti-Soviet positions in foreign policy
3. Questioned liberal welfare programs and affirmative action
4. Called for the reassertion of traditional values and centrality of the family
d. Reagan’s Characteristics
i. Had a down-home attitude
ii. Had been:
1. A sports announcer for a radio station
2. Actor
in
3. President of the Screen Actors Guild (helped purge reds from the industry)
4. Spokesman for General Electric
5. Governor of CA
e. Democratic Nomination
i. Was bungled by Carter’s inability to bring inflation down
ii. Tried to nominated Senator Edward Kennedy of MA, but it fell short when revelations about a 1969 car accident in which a young woman assistant was drowned when Kennedy’s car plunged off a bridge
iii. Carter was finally nominated
f. Republican Nomination
i. Reagan was nominated
ii. He attacked Carter’s fumbling performance in foreign policy and blasted the “big-government” philosophy of the Democratic party
iii. The high interest rates and inflation led to Carter’s doom, although he tried to counter that Reagan was a trigger-happy warrior who might push the country into nuclear war
g. Results of the Election of 1980
i. Reagan won:
1. Won 51% to 41% of the popular vote
2. 489-49
ii. Republicans gained control of the Senate for the first time in 25 years; first president voted out of office since Herbert Hoover in 1932
iii.
On Inauguration Day, January 20, 1981, after 444 days
of captivity, the
h. Carter’s Legacy
i. Accepted defeat gracefully
ii. Continued to work in foreign affairs
iii. Earned the Nobel Peace Prize in 2002
II. The Reagan Revolution
a. Scaling Down Government
i. Wanted to dismantle the welfare state and reverse the political evolution of the preceding half-century
ii. He believed that years of New Deal style tax-and-spend programs had created a federal government that was large and not responsible
b. The Facts About the Expanded Government
i. From 1960-1980, federal spending had risen from 18% of the GNP to 23%
ii. The federal budget had been shifting from defense to entitlement programs
iii. In 1973, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare surpassed the Department of Defense in budget
c. First Part of Economic Program – Cutting the Budget
i. Reagan proposed a new budget that included cuts of $35 billion in mostly social programs
d. Boll Weevils
i. To gain support of the Democratic-majority House, he wooed southern conservative Democrats who abandoned their party to follow the president, called Boll Weevils
e. Assassination Attempt On Reagan
i.
In March 1981, a deranged gunman, John Hinckley, shot
the president as he was leaving a
ii. A .22-caliber bullet penetrated beneath Reagan’s left arm and collapsed his left lung; the outpouring of sympathy was enormous
iii. 12 days after the attack, he walked out of the hospital and returned to work
iv.
III.
The
a. Second Part of Economic Program – Tax Reforms
i. Reagan also wanted deep tax cuts that amounted to 25% in all income brackets
ii. Congress approved:
1. Reducing individual tax rates
2. Reducing federal estate taxes
3. Created a tax-free savings plan for small investors
iii. The combination of budget constraints and tax reduction was called “supply-side” economics or Reaganomics. His advisors assured him that it would:
1. Stimulate investment
2. Boost productivity
3. Create dramatic economic growth
4. Reduce the federal deficit
b. The Budget Deficit Increases
i. There was a deep recession – worst since the 1930s
ii. In 1982, unemployment reached 11%
iii. Businesses went bankrupt
iv. Banks collapsed
v.
The automobile industry, once the biggest industry in
vi. Some charged that the policies of Carter had actually caused the recession; others said that the budget cuts hurt the poor and disabled, while the tax cuts favored the rich
c. The Economy Recovers
i. Reagan’s economic policies seemed to be vindicated when the economy recovered in 1983
ii. Yuppies –
1. Were young, urban professionals; numbered 1.5 million
2. They wore Rolex watches, drove BMW cars, and consumed many expensive goods
3. Showcased the values of materialism and the pursuit of wealth
d. Reality of Reaganomics
i. However, for the first time in the century, income gaps widened between the rich and poor:
1. The poor got poorer
2. The rich got richer
3. The middle class was stagnant
ii. Massive military expenditures could’ve caused the prosperity of the 80s; Reagan spent $2 trillion on defense
iii. Budget deficits ran to $200 billion per year from 1983-1989
iv. Massive government borrowing to pay for the deficit kept interest rates high and high interest rates elevated the value of the dollar abroad
v. As a result, the American international trade deficit reached a record $152 billion in 1987
IV. Reagan Renews the Cold War
a. Reagan’s Strategy With the Soviets
i.
Thought that the
ii. Believed in negotiating with the Soviets only from a position of overwhelming strength. He wanted to do this by creating a new and expensive arms race
iii. The American economy, theoretically, could better bear this new financial burden than could the creaking Soviet system. Eventually, when they were out of money, they’d have to come to the bargaining table with Reagan
b. Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI)
i. In March 1983, he announced the Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI), popularly known as Star Wars. The plan called for orbiting battle stations in space that could fire laser beams to vaporize intercontinental missiles
ii. Most scientists considered this an impossible goal, but it fit with Reagan’s arms race strategy with the Soviets
c. Solidarity
i.
In late 1981, the government of
ii.
The government of
iii.
Reagan believed that the Soviets were behind this, and
he imposed economic sanctions on
d. Increasing Tensions
i. 1982-1985
1. Three Soviet Kremlins died
ii. September 1983
1. The Soviets shot down a Korean passenger airliner that had inexplicably violated Soviet airspace
2. Hundreds of civilians, including Americans, lost their lives
iii. End of 1983
1. All arms-control negotiations with the Soviets were broken off
iv. 1984
1. The
Soviets and Soviet-bloc athletes boycotted the Olympic Games in
V. Troubles Abroad
a. Trouble
With
i.
ii.
In June 1982,
iii.
The Palestinians were subdued, but
iv. In 1983, President Reagan sent American troops as a peace-keeping force, but their presence didn’t bring peace
v. In October 1983, a suicide bomber crashed an explosives-laden truck into a U.S. Marine barrack that killed more than 200 marines
vi. Although this did nothing to sully Reagan’s reputation, he withdrew the remaining American troops shortly thereafter
b. Trouble
With
i.
A revolution (the people who led the revolution were
known as the “Sandinistas”) deposed the dictator of
ii. Carter ignored the fact that they were anti-American and tried to establish good relations with them
iii.
Reagan didn’t support having good relations with them
and he accused the Sandinistas of turning their country into a base for Soviet
and Cuban military operations for all of
iv.
After taking photographs from high-flying planes, the
administration claimed that Nicaraguan leftists were shipping weapons to
revolutionary forces in
v.
Reagan sent military “advisers” and cover aid (the CIA
mined harbors) to prop up the pro-American government of
c.
i.
In October 1983, Reagan dispatched an invasion force to
the
ii. American troops swiftly overran the island and ousted the insurgents
VI. Round Two For Reagan
a. Republican Nomination
i. Reagan won it because of his strong stature abroad and sound economy at home
b. Democratic Nomination
i. Was Walter Mondale, who named Congresswoman Geraldine Ferraro his running-mate. This would be the first women ever to appear on a major-party presidential ticket
ii. However, Mondale had served in the deeply discredited Carter administration
c. Results of the Election of 1984
i. Reagan won:
1. 52.6 million-36.5 million
2. 525-13
d. Mikhail Gorbachev
i.
Was the new, charismatic leader of the
ii.
He was personable, energetic, imaginative, and
committed to radical reforms in the
iii. He announced two policies:
1. Glasnost –
a. Means “openness”
b. Aimed to introduce free speech and some other liberties
2. Perestroika –
a. Means “restructuring”
b. Was intended to revive the Soviet economy by adopting many of the free-market practices of the capitalist West
iv.
He also removed the Soviet troops from
e. The Summit Conferences
i.
Both policies required that the Soviet
ii.
First
1. April 1985
2. The
iii.
Second
1. October 1986
2. Was a stalemate
iv.
Third
1. December 1987
2. Both
signed the INF treaty, banning all intermediate-range nuclear missiles from
v.
Fourth
1. May 1988
2. Reagan praised Gorbachev
f.
Reagan and the
i.
ii.
VII. The Iran-Contra Affair
a. Secret Dealings
i. The president repeatedly requested that Congress provide military aid to the contra rebels fighting against the left-wing Sandinista regime
ii. Congress repeatedly refused, and the administration grew increasingly frustrated and obsessed in its search for a means to help the contras
iii. In 1985, American diplomats secretly arranged arms sales to the Iranians in return for Iranian aid in obtaining the release of American hostages held by Middle Eastern terrorists
iv. Money from the payment for the arms was diverted to the contras
v. This action violated a congressional ban on military aid to the Nicaraguan rebels and Reagan’s vow that he would never negotiate with terrorists
b. The Secret Dealings Are Broken To the Public
i. News of the secret dealings broke in November 1986
ii. President Reagan claimed he was innocent of wrongdoing and ignorant about the activities of his subordinates
iii. A congressional committee concluded that “if the president did not know what his national security advisers were doing, he should have”
iv. Reagan said that
c. Results of the Iran-Contra Affair
i. Cast a shadow over Reagan’s record in foreign policy
ii. Out of the several Iran-contra investigations, a picture emerged of Reagan as a lazy and senile president who napped through meetings and paid little or no attention to the details of policy
iii. Critics claimed he acted his way through the presidency without understanding his role
iv. However, Reagan remained one of the most popular and beloved presidents
v. The congressional hearings led to the convictions of Oliver North, Robert McFarlane, and John Poindexter
vi. For many, the hearings echoed the Watergate scandal; Americans became increasingly skeptical of their government
VIII. Reagan’s Economic Legacy
a. National Debt
i. Eased many regulatory rules
ii. Pushed major tax reform bills through Congress
iii. Did not achieve a balanced budget
iv. The combination of tax reduction and huge military spending made a $200 billion dollar a year deficit
v. Added $2 trillion to the national debt (more than all predecessors combined)
vi. Because so much of the debt was financed by foreign lenders, especially the Japanese, it ensured future generations that they would have to lower their standard of living or work harder than their parents (or both) to pay off the debt
b. Slow Growth of Government
i. Reagan made new social spending practically and politically impossible for the foreseeable future, so the deficits helped to achieve that purpose. It contained the welfare state
c. Lack of Equitable Distribution of Income
i. In the early 1990s, the median household income declined from:
1. 1989 - $33,500
2. 1993 - $31,000
ii. This could be attributed to Reagan and his economic policies
IX. The Religious Right
a. Reverend Jerry Falwell
i. A coalition of conservative, evangelical Christians became known as the Religious Right
ii. In 1979, Reverend Jerry Falwell founded a political organization called the Moral Majority, which registered between 2-3 million voters
iii. He preached against:
1. Sexual permissiveness
2. Abortion
3. Feminism
4. Gay rights
iv. Using radio, direct-mail marketing, and TV, “televangelists” reached huge audiences in the 1980s and collected million of dollars for conservative causes
b. Movement Conservatives
i. The Religious Right of the 1980s was an answer to 60s radicalism
ii. Like advocates of multiculturalism and affirmative action, the Religious Right identified themselves with Christian or pro-life voters
iii. Protesters in the 1960s blocked entrances to draft offices; protesters in the 1980s blocked entrances to abortion clinics
iv. They articulated their positions in a language of rights and entitlements, as in the “right-to-life” (or anti-abortion) movement
c. End of the Religious Right?
i. As the decade ended, several leaders got into trouble
ii. However, it didn’t diminish conservative Christians political clout
X. Conservatism in the Courts
a. Culture War
i. Appointed a near-majority of all sitting judges in the Supreme Court, including 3 conservatives
ii. Nominated Sandra Day O’Connor, who became the first woman to be on the Supreme Court, on September 1981
b. Rolling Back Affirmative Action
i. Ruled that:
1. Union rules about job seniority could outweigh affirmative action
2. Made it more difficult to prove that an employer practiced racial discrimination in hiring
3. Made it easier for white males to argue that they were the victims of reverse discrimination by employers who followed affirmative-action practices
c. Rolling Back Abortion Rights
i. Webster v. Reproductive Health Services (1989)
1. Approved
a
2. Made it possible for State to make laws regarding abortion
ii. Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992)
1. The
Court held that
2. Made it possible for States to restrict access to abortion as long as they did not place an “undue burden” on the woman
XI. Referendum On Reaganism in 1988
a. Democrats Fight Back
i. Democrats gained control of the Senate in November 1986
ii. Rejected Robert Bork, an ultraconservative, as a nominee for the Supreme Court
iii. To discredit Reagan, they used:
1. Signs of economic trouble
2. Iran-contra scandal
3. Alleged unethical behavior by Reagan’s advisors
b. Savings and Loan Scandal and Black Monday
i. The growing federal budget deficit and the international trade deficit hurt the economy
ii.
The savings and loan industry found themselves holding
near-worthless loans they had unwisely given to Third World countries,
especially in
iii. In 1984, it took federal assistance to save Continental Illinois Bank (one of the nation’s biggest banks) from bankruptcy. More banks and savings institutions were folding than at any time since the Great Depression. A wave of mergers, acquisitions, and buyouts occurred in Wall Street
iv. On October 19, 1987, Black Monday occurred the stock-market plunged 508 points – the largest one-day decline in history
v. The federal government guaranteed deposits up to $100,000 and a $166 billion rescue appropriation was made
vi. The “scandal” is representative of the effects of poor government regulation
c. Democratic Nomination
i. Seven Democrats (called the Seven Dwarfs) hoped to cash in on the economic scare by winning the presidency. Some of them were:
1. Gary
Hart – Senator from
2. Jesse Jackson – a rousing speechmaker and minister
3. Michael Dukakis – Governor of MA
ii. Dukakis was finally nominated as the Democratic candidate
d. Republican Nomination
i. Nominated Reagan’s vice-president, George H.W. Bush
ii. He ran on the Reagan record of:
1. Tax cuts
2. Strong defense policies
3. Toughness on crime
4. Opposition to abortion
5. Economic expansion
e. Results of the Election of 1988
i. Dukakis couldn’t exploit the weaknesses of the Republicans and came across as devoid of emotion and not very smart
ii. Bush won:
1. 48 million-41 million
2. 426-111
XII. George H.W. Bush and the End of the Cold War
a. Characteristics of George H.W. Bush
i.
His father served as a U.S. Senator from
ii. Was educated at Yale
iii. Served in WWII
iv. Amassed a modest fortune in the oil business in TX
v. Served as a congressman
vi.
Was emissary to
vii. Ambassador to the UN
viii. Director of the CIA
ix. Vice president
b.
i.
In 1989, hundreds of thousands of pro-democracy
demonstrators gathered in
ii.
In June,
iii. World opinion condemned the bloody suppression of the pro-democracy demonstrators
iv.
Despite demands in Congress for restrictions on trade
with
c. The Fall of Communism
i. August 1989
1. The
Solidarity movement in
ii. September-November 1989
1. The
communist regimes collapsed in
iii. December 1989
1. The Berlin Wall fell
2. This marked the beginning of the end of the Cold War
iv. October 1990
1.
v. August 1991
1. Mikahil Gorbachev’s policies of glasnost and perestroika caused the old-guard communists to want to preserve the system
2. They
tried a military coup, but it was foiled with the help of
vi. December 1991
1. Gorbachev resigned as Soviet president
2. The
Soviet Union had dissolved into 15 republics loosely confederated in the
Commonwealth of Independent State (CIS), with
3. To varying degrees, all the new governments in the CIS repudiated communism and embraced democratic reforms and free-market economies
d. Results
of the Fall of the
i.
The demise of the
ii.
No more tension over nuclear war between the
iii. It also marked the virtual end of communism world-wide
iv. Democracy now had no more ideological battles left to fight
e. Probing
Questions About the Fall of the
i.
Who would honor treaties with the
ii. Which of the successor states would take command of the Soviet nuclear arsenal?
iii. Would its nuclear weapons be traded on the black market?
f. START
i. In early 1993, Bush and Yeltsin agreed to this treaty, which committed both powers to reduce their long-range nuclear arsenals by 2/3 within 10 years
ii.
This eased tensions (over the questions above) between
the
g. Ethnic Clashes
i.
1. In
1991, a Chechnyan minority tried to declare their
independence from
2. This prompted President Yeltsin to send in Russian troops
3. They still have problems with the Chechnyans to this day
ii.
1. Ethnicities
in
2. This caused ethnic clashes and genocide that lingered into the late 1990s
iii.
Communism had contained ethnicities in
iv. As a result, the Western European economies strained by absorbing these technologically backward peoples
h. American Questions After the End of the Cold War
i.
With the Soviet threat now gone, would the
ii. What principles would guide American diplomacy now that “anticommunism” had lost its relevance?
i. American Economic and Military Change
i. Huge economic sectors, such as aerospace, were heavily sustained by military contracts. In 1991, the Pentagon canceled a $52 billion contract for navy attack planes
ii. 34 military bases also closed
iii. Defense plants shut down and unemployment soared; more closings and cancellations followed
j. Peace
i.
1. In 1990, apartied ended
2. It freed African leader Nelson Mandela, who had served 27 years in prison for conspiring to overthrow the government
3. Four
years later, he was elected
ii.
1. In
February 1990, free elections in
iii.
1. In 1992, peace came after the civil war that was raging in this country
XIII.
The
a.
i. In December 1989, Bush sent airborne troops to capture dictator and drug lord Manuel Noriega
b. Why
i.
Saddam Hussein, the brutal dictator of
1. Wanted
their oil to pay their bills because they were financially exhausted after an
8-year war with
2. Wanted
control over the entire
3. Wanted control of the world’s oil
4. Wanted
to get rid of the Arabs’ enemy,
c.
i.
Although the
ii. He had been widely known as a thug and assassin who intimidated his underlings by showing them the bodies of his executed adversaries hanging on meat hooks
d. Saddam
Invades
i. August 2, 1990
1. Saddam
sent his army to
ii. August 3, 1990
1. The
UN Security Council unanimously condemned the invasion and demanded the
immediate withdrawal of
iii. November 1990
1. The
Security Council issued an ultimatum for Saddam to leave
iv. November 1990-January 1990
1. The
2. They were joined by nearly 270,000 troops from 28 other countries
v. January 12, 1991
1. Congress
approved the use of force in
vi. January 16, 1991
1. The
2.
vii. February 23, 1991
1. Operation Desert Storm, the land invasion, began
viii. February 27, 1991
1. Saddam
agrees to a cease-fire and
e. During the War
i.
The allied commander, General Norman Schwarzkopf, took
nothing for granted (he wanted to soften
ii. Saddam had chemical and biological weapons, including poison gas and anthrax
iii.
He also used ecological warfare, as he released a
gigantic oil slick in the
f. Aftermath of the War
i.
Saddam survived the war and continued to be the dictator
of
ii.
The
XIV. Bush on the Home Front
a. New Legislation
i.
American With Disabilities Act of 1990 (
1. Prohibited
discrimination against 43 million
ii. Water Projects Bill
1. Put the interests of the environment ahead of agriculture
2. Made water more available to cities
b. Social Issues
i. Bush’s Department of Education challenged the legality of college scholarships targeted for racial minorities
ii. Bush repeatedly threatened to veto civil rights legislation that would make it easier for employees to prove discrimination in hiring practices
c. Clarence Thomas
i. In 1991, Bush nominated a conservative, Clarence Thomas, to the Supreme Court
ii. Although an African American, he opposed affirmative action and was opposed by the NAACP
iii. Because of his controversial views on abortion and affirmative action, the Senate Judiciary Committee voted 7-7 on him and left it up to the full Senate to decide on whether to affirm or reject his appointment
iv.
Then, a press leak revealed that Anita Hill, a law
professor at the
v. The Senate Judiciary Committee was forced to reopen its hearings, which were televised. All the graphic sexual detail was out in the open
vi. In the end, the Senate voted 52-48 to confirm Thomas’ appointment
vii. Some applauded Hill for focusing the nation’s attention on the issues of sexual harassment, while Thomas maintained that it was a “high-tech lynching for uppity blacks…”
d. Women and the President
i. Didn’t like how the all-male committee handled the Thomas hearings
ii. Didn’t like the President’s antiabortion stand
iii. A “gender gap” opened between the two political parties as more women increasingly voted with the Democrats
e. Economy
i.
By 1992, the unemployment rate was over 7% and over 10%
in the key State of
ii. The federal budget deficit topped $250 billion each year
iii. In 1990, Bush agreed to increase taxes to generate $133 billion, reneging on his campaign promise not to raise taxes